Practicing Past the Dots

Posted on

Georges_Seurat__Un_dimanche_aprsmidi__lle_de_la_Grande_Jatte.jpgAre you practicing the big picture, or do you get stuck in “the dots?”

Music is an art, a joint creation by composer and performer, designed to communicate to a listener.  As a performing medium, music is also an art “of the moment.” When we hear live music, we hear something that will never exist again. That note is over, that crescendo is gone, that sublimely beautiful moment has evaporated into the atmosphere. When we perform music, our music is only alive in each moment as it happens.

It’s easy to see why we strive for perfection. We have only one chance in a live performance to make the impression we want, to create the musical mood we want, to play the note correctly.

But if that becomes a primary focus, or even our sole focus, in our preparation or in our performance, we lose the opportunity to create and enjoy everything that is wonderful about music. Mostly, we lose focus on the music as a whole, and replace it with a much more self-conscious and even self-centered view.

It’s not about us, not about the flashy technique we have or the mistakes we make. It’s about music, it’s about the partnership with the composer, it’s about the musical story we are telling the listener. And if your preparation isn’t leading you there, to that place where the notes are merely the dots on the canvas that create the picture, you need to redirect your efforts.

Consider the famous painting by Georges Seurat, “A Sunday on La Grande Jatte.”  It’s an enormous painting, about 7 feet by 10 feet, and it’s composed entirely of tiny dots.

This entire huge canvas is filled with little dots of paint, applied one at a time, that together create this scene of French society on a Sunday afternoon. Seurat was influenced by the Impressionist painters, notably Monet and Pissarro, but he developed his own unique style of painting which came to be called pointillism.  What is remarkable about pointillist painting in general and Seurat’s masterpiece particularly is that the scene depicted in the painting is only visible at a distance. When we stand too close, all we see are the millions of tiny dots of paint. It’s only when we stand at a little distance that we can see what Seurat wanted us to see. Taken singly, not one of those dots would signify much. Taken together, we see Seurat’s vision.

And that vision was critical. If Seurat hadn’t known the larger purpose of those dots, the people out for their Sunday stroll would never come to life for a viewer. Each of those dots is only meaningful in the larger context of the picture.

In a similar way, sometimes we “stand too close” when we practice. We place so much importance on the notes that we lose sight of the reality – each of those notes is only one note in the larger scope of the entire piece. We want a listener to hear the whole piece, not just the notes, and we must practice with that bigger musical vision in focus. Obviously, there is a balance point. If too many notes are incorrect, then the listener’s perception of the music is marred. The attention is drawn to the “dots” instead of the picture.

But if our vision never gets beyond the dots, how can we expect a listener to hear beyond them?

Tags: , , , , ,

  • Val Brady

    Anne, I loved this. Puts the whole music thing in perspective. The way you think about music and the way you lead me to think about music is magical. Thank you.



  • Lorna Ota

    Dear Anne, I’m assuming this is your original writing. It is written in such a lovely and understanding way, that it gives me a whole new perspective in learning new pieces. Beginning with learning about the composer seems to be a very good start. What emoted his/her passions that inspired the composition to grow and meld into such beautiful music? If I study each task as you suggest, perhaps I’ll be able to understand the purpose of the key signature, rhythm, notes, dynamics, etc, and not so much in the details one thing, then I might just be able to move ahead…faster. Everything you’ve shared thus far: “practice, study, practice, study, etc., will surely help me to reach my goal in building a more interesting repertoire. Practice time is very scarce for me due to many other commitments. But since harp music is very healing to and for me and for those who listen to my playing, it’s worth learning just the way you suggest. Thank you for your treasures of learning to play the harp with undeniable diligence. I’m a slow learner, but I think I’m getting the idea….slow, but surely! “MAHALO NUI LOA” (Haw’n – TYVVM!) Lorna


  • Regina

    This is just the loveliest article, using Seurat’s painting as an analogy. Gives vivid understanding.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *